NFL

NFL’s Highest-Paid Quarterbacks Who Have Never Won A Playoff Game

Disclosure
We publish independently audited information that meets our strong editorial guidelines. Be aware we may earn a commission if you purchase anything via links on our pages.
Carolina Panthers quarterback Andy Dalton (14).

Sportscasting.com collected and analyzed the data for the list of the NFL’s highest-paid quarterbacks who have never won a playoff game.

Key Highlights

  • Derek Carr ($195.7 million) is the highest-paid quarterback who has never won a playoff game (0-1).
  • Andy Dalton ($110.6 million) is tied with Y.A. Tittle for the most career playoff starts without winning a game (0-4).
  • 8 of the 10 highest-paid quarterbacks who have never won a playoff game are on active rosters.

Derek Carr, Kyler Murray Headline The List

New Orleans Saints quarterback Derek Carr is the highest-paid quarterback to have never won a playoff game. Through 2024, Carr’s career earnings exceed $195 million.

Carr started his one playoff game during the 2021 NFL season for the Las Vegas Raiders. Carr completed 29 of 54 for 310 yards, one touchdown, and one interception in the Raiders’ 26-19 loss to the Cincinnati Bengals in the Wild Card round.

Arizona Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray is second on the list at $138.1 million. During the 2021 NFL season, Murray led the Cardinals to an 11-6 regular season record. The Cardinals lost 34-11 in the Wild Card game to the eventual Super Bowl champion, the Los Angeles Rams.

Carolina Panthers quarterback Andy Dalton, the fifth-highest quarterback on the list, is tied with Y.A. Tittle for the most playoff starts (4) without a victory. Dalton’s last playoff start came during the 2014 season for the Cincinnati Bengals, losing to the Indianapolis Colts in the Wild Card round.

Eight of the 10 quarterbacks on the list are still in the NFL. During their careers, Sam Bradford and Ryan Fitzpatrick never started playoff games.

NFL’s Highest-Paid QBs Who Have Never Won A Playoff Game

Player Career Earnings Playoff Record
Derek Carr* $195.7 million 0-1
Kyler Murray* $138.1 million 0-1
Carson Wentz* $132.8 million 0-1
Sam Bradford $130 million 0-0
Andy Dalton* $110.6 million 0-4
Justin Herbert* $96.2 million 0-1
Ryan Fitzpatrick $82.1 million 0-0
Tyrod Taylor* $76.6 million 0-1
Jameis Winston* $76.1 million 0-0
Tua Tagavailoa* $73.5 million 0-1

*Active players.
Numbers via Spotrac.com on 10/30/2024.

Author photo
Dan Girolamo
Sports Editor

Dan is a multifaceted content creator who specializes in sports, pop culture, and entertainment. His entertainment work has been featured on Digital Trends, where he has interviewed Brendan Fraser, Jamie Lee Curtis, Alison Brie, Adam DeVine, Sadie Sink, Chris O'Dowd, Machine Gun Kelly, and Frank Grillo. Dan's entertainment work has also been featured on Coming Soon, Hidden Remote, and WatchMojo. Dan's other passion in life revolves around sports, graduating from Marist College with a degree in Sports Communication and Journalism. From columns about the latest in New York sports to gambling predictions, Dan continues to find success in written and broadcast journalism. Previous written work can be found at Unafraid Show, while broadcast clips can be seen on WAVE.tv and CBS Sports.

Get to know Dan Girolamo better
Author photo
Dan Girolamo Sports Editor

Dan is a multifaceted content creator who specializes in sports, pop culture, and entertainment. His entertainment work has been featured on Digital Trends, where he has interviewed Brendan Fraser, Jamie Lee Curtis, Alison Brie, Adam DeVine, Sadie Sink, Chris O'Dowd, Machine Gun Kelly, and Frank Grillo. Dan's entertainment work has also been featured on Coming Soon, Hidden Remote, and WatchMojo. Dan's other passion in life revolves around sports, graduating from Marist College with a degree in Sports Communication and Journalism. From columns about the latest in New York sports to gambling predictions, Dan continues to find success in written and broadcast journalism. Previous written work can be found at Unafraid Show, while broadcast clips can be seen on WAVE.tv and CBS Sports.

All posts by Dan Girolamo